Anonymous asked: going by just the show, do you think RS-Roll could defeat RS-Protoman in a fight
My gut reaction is ‘Yeah, no problem.’ But maybe you want more of an analysis then that, no?
Roll and Proto Man have never fought together in the cartoons, the closest we have is her getting captured (see The Big Shake, The Mega Man in The Moon, and Bro Bots) without her so much as lifting a nail file in self defense. (Maybe Proto Man discreetly disarmed her before he snatches? Who knows)
But if we assume an equal fight on equal footing (and that Proto Man won’t cheaply disarm her like his brother does with Robot Masters), then it comes down to his brains against her brains, his might against her might, plasma cannon vs utility arm.
And as fighting goes, Roll’s no shrinking violet. She’s beaten up several Robot Masters—Cut Man, Guts Man, Bright Man, Hard Man, Top Man, Elec Man, Fire Man, Quick Man, plus anyone I’m forgetting.

…though I don’t know if crushing someone’s titanium skull in with a marble statue counts as a ‘fair’ fight. I suppose it depends on whether you consider Roll to be handicapped or whatever.

As far as weapons, it’s impossible to know the entire contents of Roll’s utility arm because the show never appeared to give it a limit. She’s sort of like Inspector Gadget with an arsenal of super-charged shit. She has a vacuum which can suck up weapons and rebound them at the attacker, a toaster blaster so powerful than it knocks her on her butt, projectile saws, a garbage disposal that can rip apart regular sized Robot Masters, and not to mention several slicing and bludgeoning weapons like axes and hockey sticks. Actually, the weapons she uses to fight bad guys are kinda sick, when you think about it. Getting fatally blasted through the chest by a plasma cannon?—that’s a somewhat honorable way to lose a duel. But getting a stone-grinding cake mixer to the face? Holy shit, that’s some hardcore guerrilla warfare tactics there! And Roll has nooooooo problem with defiling bodies.

(To be fair, everyone is pretty brutal to each other in the cartoon. It’s one of those things where animators can be as violent as they want and it still squeak by with a G rating because the characters are robots.)
So the utility arm should be able to hold its own against a plasma cannon in terms of lethalness. On the other hand, she’s also unarmored, and one plasma blast could do her in. But since Proto Man’s blaster has about a 1/8 chance of hitting his intended target, Roll has a pretty good chance of closing in for the fatality anyway.
As for Proto Man? Well…let me say it this way, Proto Man’s fighting records don’t live up to his charmingly snarky personality and rad looks. (Sorry Proto Man! It’s all part of the cosmic joke related to being Blues/Proto Man!)
If we went strictly by the cartoons, they wouldn’t fight at all and Roll gets captured. If we inferred from between the lines of the cartoon, well, they’re both prone to cheating so it depends on who gets the jump on who first. But in a fair fight? I dunno, the laws of physics are so loosely defined in the RS-world, they could be evenly matched, with a favor towards Roll since she tends to win more of her battles than he does. Especially if it’s an ‘My name is Inigo Montoya, you killed my brother, prepare to die!’ situation where she wants it more.
Well, since I can’t answer this definitively, I have asked an ‘ask Roll’ blog and an Protoman RP blog what they think, and, if they so choose to respond, maybe we’ll get an answer there, though I’m willing to bet all my memory chips that these robots aren’t going to agree with one another on the outcome of their battle. ;)